PDA

View Full Version : Homeowner not being charged in fatal shooting at this time



wildcard
1st May 2010, 04:16 PM
Police: Homeowner not being charged in fatal shooting at this time

http://www.wtoc.com/Global/story.asp?S=12391185

http://wmbf.images.worldnow.com/images/12391185_BG6.jpg
Dead burglar.

http://wmbf.images.worldnow.com/images/12391185_BG5.jpg
Straight shootin' homeowner.

http://wmbf.images.worldnow.com/images/12391185_BG7.jpg
Another burglar who is now in a whole lot of trouble.


CONWAY, SC (WMBF) - Horry County Police say a Conway homeowner who shot and killed a man who threatened him and his wife at gunpoint is not facing charges at this time.

Sgt. Robert Kegler, spokesman for the Horry County Police Department, says officers were dispatched to a home at 3140 Wayside Dr. in Conway in reference to a home invasion and shooting. Upon arrival, investigators learned the homeowner shot and killed one of three suspects who broke into his home, demanding money and valuables.

Tony Hendrick of the Horry County Coroner's Office identified the man who was killed as Anthony Andre Browne Jr., 23, of Conway.

James Gagum says at least four shots were fired during the incident, one of which went through his home.

"It was him instead of me or me instead of him," Gagum said, noting Browne pointed a gun at him and his wife.

All three intruders fled the scene, but officials found Browne's body in a wooded area next to the location of the home invasion.

"He could not have ran that far because I knew I shot him with a .357 three times, square in the mid-section," Gagum recalled hours after the man's death.

Investigators questioned Gagum about the shooting, and he was released. Gagum contends he was just protecting his life, family and property. Kegler said Thursday that he will not be charged.

"You're left between them killing you now, or you killing them," Gagum said. "That's where we're coming to. It's coming to that point."

Two other suspects involved in the home invasion were believed to have fled in a blue SUV. A man and woman were taken into custody in Loris later Wednesday.

Kegler says the man, identified as David Graham, 34, of Loris, has been charged with first degree burglary, two counts of armed robbery, two counts of kidnapping and possession of a firearm during the commission of a crime.

Kegler says investigators are looking for a third person of interest at this time, but do not have a description.

Kegler says Gagum is not facing charges in the incident. Gagum says he was acting in self-defense.

Attorney Kirk Truslow, who is not affiliated with the case, says if someone is trying to break-in on a person's property, that person has the right to defend themselves. It's what South Carolina law calls the "Castle Doctrine."

"The rule in South Carolina has always been if you are in your own house, you do not have a duty to retreat," explained Truslow. "You can stand your ground [and] establish self defense without worry of the duty to retreat. That is known as the Castle Doctrine, and that's been law throughout the cases in case law."

Truslow says the doctrine has now been adopted into state law, and there is no requirement for having to run away or retreat from your home to protect yourself.

"In self defense, you can meet a threat with as much force as necessary to defend yourself, if you reasonably believe you are in fear of harm," said Truslow.

Glass
1st May 2010, 04:30 PM
Ah yes, the common law



"The rule in South Carolina has always been if you are in your own house, you do not have a duty to retreat," explained Truslow. "You can stand your ground [and] establish self defense without worry of the duty to retreat. That is known as the Castle Doctrine, and that's been law throughout the cases in case law."


It's been the law since the begining. The common law gives us many rights that the government want to take away. Self Defence in the home is one. I guess it's good to see it recognized, even if they have codified it now.

Book
1st May 2010, 04:43 PM
Ever notice that the criminals are always wearing orange smocks?

Conclusion: Never open your door to guys wearing orange smocks.

^-^

Apparition
1st May 2010, 04:45 PM
Bravo to the homeowner.

ximmy
1st May 2010, 04:50 PM
dead man's family will sue... why he gotta shoot him three times...

wildcard
1st May 2010, 04:59 PM
He was such a good boy! He was making progress in his cancer research! He was on the edge of a break-through! ::)

General of Darkness
1st May 2010, 05:07 PM
Good for him.

Olmstein
1st May 2010, 05:09 PM
dead man's family will sue... why he gotta shoot him three times...


...........

Book
1st May 2010, 05:15 PM
He was such a good boy! He was making progress in his cancer research! He was on the edge of a break-through! ::)


http://thecia.com.au/reviews/b/images/big-momma-s-house-2-1.jpg

Shush! He was always a good boy!

Ironfield
1st May 2010, 09:15 PM
Ever notice that the criminals are always wearing orange smocks?

Conclusion: Never open your door to guys wearing orange smocks.

^-^




Yep good advice. On a more serious note 99% of the time, this lot are repeat offenders and the first photo on hand for news bulletins are their previous mug shots. Criminal justice system needs to be overhauled I know most don't agree but I'm a strong supporter of corporal punishment.

[quote=Glass]
"The rule in South Carolina has always been if you are in your own house, you do not have a duty to retreat," explained Truslow. "You can stand your ground [and] establish self defense without worry of the duty to retreat. That is known as the Castle Doctrine, and that's been law throughout the cases in case law."

It's been the law since the beginning. The common law gives us many rights that the government want to take away. Self Defense in the home is one. I guess it's good to see it recognized, even if they have codified it now.[quote]

Whilst I agree that everyone should be able to use and implement common law, at least an honest home owner isn't going to be prosecuted for defending his family and himself in his own home unlike if this was to go down in Europe or Australia.

-Ironfield

silver_surfer
1st May 2010, 09:50 PM
Good shoot

Heimdhal
1st May 2010, 10:17 PM
dead man's family will sue... why he gotta shoot him three times...


Not sure about SC, but in MOST states with castle doctrine, so I am assuming it is so in SC, if you are "cleared" by a grand jury of wrong doing, there can be no civil case brought against you by anyone. Same I believe if you wind up going to trial and are aquited or have the charges dropped.

That doesnt mean they wont try or they wont raise a stink about it though.

willie pete
1st May 2010, 10:31 PM
If someone home invades you in Florida, it's open season..