PDA

View Full Version : Your Info is Not Private as a Bidder on EBAY



MNeagle
29th August 2010, 06:26 PM
On Friday, I mentioned an oddity on Amazon that I thought was weird: I could not complete the buying process until I agreed to sign up for Amazon Prime. (I did, then called and canceled). So far, it appears to have been a one time glitch.

The latest online idiocy I encountered involved eBay. Truth be told, I really like Amazon, but — I was never much of a fan of Bay’s auction site. I especially detest their miserable payment process Paypal. This is a bank pretending to be an online service, but they are not kidding anyone — Paypal is a bank, and they absolutely should be regulated like one.

Where was I? Ahh, the latest idiocy: I occasionally bid on expensive items but at prices below fair value. Unlike high frequency traders, I stand ready to buy the item at my bid prices.

My latest was a $35,000 bid for a Maserati Gran Turismo convertible. Its a $100k+ car; I am always willing to buy slick sheet metal $100k off of list price.

I placed the bid and forgot about it. Until the next day, when — WTF? — a used car salesman called me at home about selling me the Gran Turismo. I was surprised, for I had been laboring under the apparent misconception that my bid (as well as all of mt private contact info) were private.

I told the sales guy I did not appreciate the sales call when I was bidding anonymously for the vehicle — he informed me it was common place, that they hardly sell any cars on eBay, but it eventually leads to other sales.

Thus, I learned 3 things: 1) It seems your info as a bidder is far from private on eBay. 2) Sellers apparently see all of your info (or at least enough to track down your home phone number). 3) Some sellers are apparently using eBay Motors as a lead generator.

From an investor perspective, I cannot imagine that this is a good development for EBAY. There are literally 100s of thousands (if not millions) of listings on eBay Motors. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that some used car dealers have decided to go direct, backdooring eBay.

The question is, does eBay know about this? If so, what are they doing about it.

>

2010 Maserati Gran Turismo Convertible:

http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/maser-GT.jpg

link (http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/2010/08/info-not-private-ebay/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+TheBigPicture+%28The+Big+Pict ure%29)

Grand Master Melon
29th August 2010, 06:32 PM
You used to be able to see who was bidding and everything. Ebay is less transparent but as a bidder the seller has a right to know who his potential buyer is so they put in a request for your info. I think what the seller did was shady. That being said, back when you could see what people were bidding on, I would watch items I had and contact the runner up bidder to see if they were willing to buy my item at the bid they made on the item they lost on from some other seller. It was cool because they were already willing to spend the money and I didn't waste my time listing something that wouldn't sell, a win win for us both.

Ebay has really gone down the crapper though.