PDA

View Full Version : The Canadian Dollar is No Haven from a US Dollar Collapse



Serpo
1st June 2011, 04:07 AM
http://news.goldseek.com/GoldSeek/1306908360.phpBy: Jeff Berwick – The Dollar Vigilante

We spend a lot of time here at The Dollar Vigilante chastising Ben Bernanke and the Federal Reserve and preparing our subscribers for a collapse of the US dollar - something which has been paying off very handsomely, with gold and silver at record highs this year - but don't take that to mean that we prefer any other fiat currency. No fiat currency in the western world is any better than the US Dollar. In fact, in every case, they are worse.

The Federal Reserve is still, despite its secrecy, one of the most transparent central banks in the world. It also has, over the last century, despite inflating the dollar downward by 97%, been one of the least inflationary banks.

We often hear of people denounce the US dollar and correctly divine that it is headed to worthlessness, but, in the same breath, they say they own other fiat currencies like the Canadian dollar.

This is a case of ignorance of the workings of banks like the Bank of Canada - or virtually any other major central bank in the world, for that matter.

There are numerous reasons why the Canadian dollar will not survive a US dollar collapse:
The Canadian economy is very tied to the US economy
The Canadian Government is intent on devaluing the Canadian dollar alongside the US
The Bank of Canada has virtually no gold backing the Canadian dollar
All that does back the Canadian dollar is the US dollar and other fiat currencies
The Canadian dollar is not used globally

The Canadian Economy is Very Tied to the US Economy

We need only show one graphic to make this point:




It is obvious that if the US goes through a monetary collapse or even just a major depression, the Canadian economy will be hobbled significantly.

The Canadian Government is intent on devaluing the Canadian dollar alongside the US

The Canadian Government has made it painfully clear that they have no intention of allowing the Canadian dollar to rise much more than par with the US dollar. The reason: lobby groups and voting blocks from export based industries will depose of any government which allows this to happen.



The Bank of Canada has virtually no gold backing the Canadian dollar

Since 1980, Canada has sold 99.5% of it gold. Canada now has the 78th largest holding of gold of all countries. Countries such as Bolivia, Bangladesh, Cambodia and Macedonia have more gold than does the Bank of Canada.

The Bank of Canada used to have 653 tonnes but today it only holds 3.4 tonnes. To give a rough idea of what all of Canada's gold holdings look like, we created this rough estimate of what it would look like if Canadian Prime Minister, Stephen Harper, was standing beside it:





All that does back the Canadian dollar is the US dollar and other fiat currencies

If you believe that the US dollar is headed to zero then it makes no sense to own the Canadian dollar. Practically all that backs the Canadian dollar is US dollars.




The Canadian dollar is not used globally

The Canadian dollar is not a true global currency. There is only one, current, true global currency: the US dollar. It is accepted on the streets of New Delhi, Phnom Penh, Buenos Aires, Moscow and practically everywhere. Try bringing some Canadian monopoly money to Shanghai and try buying some street noodles. You'll see how valid of a global currency the Canadian dollar is. No soup for you!

SWRichmond
1st June 2011, 05:59 AM
Canada has natural resources which they are allowed to develop, enabling them to generate foreign exchange and maintain their balance of payments. Like Norway.

http://www.tradingeconomics.com/canada/balance-of-trade

Change the date range on the chart to 1980 - 2011 and refresh.

This post is simplistic and misses the mark by a mile. The Canadian dollar is backed by the host nation's ability to produce real goods in foreign exchange. This is the critical difference between it and the U.S. Federal Reserve Note, which is backed by a printing press and a lot of lying politicians.

gunDriller
1st June 2011, 07:12 AM
the Can$ rose to 1.08 $US in 2008.

it got as high as 1.05 back in April when the dollar was crumbling.

the Canadian government is in much better shape than the US, deficit wise, but they really are tied to the US economy.

but that can change - China is buying Can. resources, Russia is diversifying into Can$.

SHTF2010
1st June 2011, 07:21 AM
Canada is like the smaller economic siamese twin to the US

if anyone in Canada thinks we will bypass any economic upheaval that befalls the US

GIVE YOUR HEAD A SHAKE !!!!

Awoke
1st June 2011, 09:44 AM
Our dollar only rose because the USD is taking a dump.

Also, although we have natural resources, we also have shitty trade agreements like NAFTA and others that force us to sell our resources (Timber, for example) at wholesale bargain basement prices, and then forces us to buy it back at an increased price if we need more than our personal allotment can provide for.

If the US collapses, Canada collapses too. End of story.

Ponce
1st June 2011, 10:22 AM
I am with SW on this, the Canadian Dollar can stand on its own two feet and if anything the US Dollar is holding it back........Canada has the back up of its natural resourses for their dollar plus their export, it you were to aligned all their import and export you would see that they are about even.......when compared to the US they are in heaven.

First post of the day..........good morning to one and all.