vacuum
13th September 2013, 11:21 AM
So apple's new iphones can read the fingerprints of the user which is touching the screen. Most people say it's no big deal, because they are already in one or more government fingerprint databases. While this new database will be much more organized, massive, and reliable, that's not the main concern with these new fingerprint readers. There are two other big issues:
- It links the real identity of the user with the online identity of the user. In other words, you become provably legally responsible for any actions taken online or using the phone because now there is proof you were actually the person using it, rather than the possibility somebody else was using your phone. There's a hard biometric link it was you.
- Moving away from passwords and moving towards fingerprints or other biometric identification methods removes your 5th amendment right not to incriminate yourself. Legally, you can't be forced to give up a password because you have the right not to self incriminate. Furthermore, you might not know or remember the password. If instead you use a fingerprint, you can be forced to give that up, similar to giving up a key or some other physical object.
So even if it's true that the phone never sends the fingerprint to the network as they claim, these two big issues still remain.
- It links the real identity of the user with the online identity of the user. In other words, you become provably legally responsible for any actions taken online or using the phone because now there is proof you were actually the person using it, rather than the possibility somebody else was using your phone. There's a hard biometric link it was you.
- Moving away from passwords and moving towards fingerprints or other biometric identification methods removes your 5th amendment right not to incriminate yourself. Legally, you can't be forced to give up a password because you have the right not to self incriminate. Furthermore, you might not know or remember the password. If instead you use a fingerprint, you can be forced to give that up, similar to giving up a key or some other physical object.
So even if it's true that the phone never sends the fingerprint to the network as they claim, these two big issues still remain.