Log in

View Full Version : Bear spray test



Hitch
28th August 2017, 10:19 PM
I tested an old can of bear pepper spray, dated to expire in 2011, this afternoon. I've kept this can in my vehicle for the 2 legged bears, but thankfully never needed it.

My father and mother are leaving for a long camping trip into bear country, so I told them about this product. I thought it might be a good idea for them to bring it. I offered them my can, though didn't realize that it expired 6 years ago. Once I realized just how old this thing was, well...

So, my father and I took it out back, to see what this old bear spray could do...

Wow. The spray blasted out of the can with a big whoosh reaching out maybe 30-40 feet. It was high pressured, all pepper and power. Cock and balls, in a can. If you hit someone directly in the face with this product, you'd disable them from the attack, instantly. Any living thing would drop from this stuff.

6 years expired, and, would have saved my life if I needed it. I'll be replacing this shortly.

This is the product:

http://www.mace.com/mace-bear-pepper-spray

crimethink
28th August 2017, 11:46 PM
Expiration dates are "we guarantee this to work by" and not truly "this product will be worthless after this date." Almost always a legal liability matter, and not a functionality matter.

Not that I care if one needs to use it for self-defense, but there is potentially civil & criminal liability if one uses "bear spray" on humans and humanoids, even for self-defense.* Will you be prosecuted if you use it for bona fide self-defense? Probably not, even in California. Could you be sued? Much more likely. "My client was only trying to make new friends by letting himself into the house, and the defendant used bear spray on him, inconsistent with its labeling!"


* Bear spray is legal in nearly all states for bears, but many states prohibit "tear gas weapons" against humans/humanoids. In California, the legal limit for peons (non-cops, non-elite) on pepper spray ("tear gas weapon") is 2.5 ounces (70 grams). Bear spray is usually three or four times that.

Hitch
28th August 2017, 11:54 PM
I hear ya, but if my life is threatened, and all I've got to defend myself is this bear spray. I'll use it. This is CA, I can't keep a loaded gun in my car.

Bear spray is legal to keep. If you have a camper, like me, you need it for bears anyway. If a person attacks you, and it's all you've got to defend yourself, and you use it, while in fear for your life....what court is going to argue that? I doubt a blast of pepper would even prompt someone to file a civil suit. It's a temporary learning lesson pain. :) It'll go away, but the lesson should remain permanent.

crimethink
29th August 2017, 12:02 AM
I hear ya, but if my life is threatened, and all I've got to defend myself is this bear spray. I'll use it. This is CA, I can't keep a loaded gun in my car.

Bear spray is legal to keep. If you have a camper, like me, you need it for bears anyway. If a person attacks you, and it's all you've got to defend yourself, and you use it, while in fear for your life....what court is going to argue that? I doubt a blast of pepper would even prompt someone to file a civil suit. It's a temporary learning lesson pain. :) It'll go away, but the lesson should remain permanent.

Oh, no question: use it if you're under attack, by a bear or a two-legged predator. Judged by 12 rather than carried by 6, if it even gets to that.

crimethink
29th August 2017, 12:04 AM
In addition to being chemically more powerful than people pepper spray, bear spray is like a flamethrower compared to the typical keychain pepper spray:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJEnJnW68Mo


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oPKkBS4f4bc

hoarder
29th August 2017, 06:35 AM
My bear spray is a S&W .44 Magnum. It sprays lead.

I had a large can of bear spray years ago and I had similar results when I tested it years after expiration. What usually goes wrong with spray products is partial solidification of the liquid resulting in clogging. Since pepper spray is an organic compound I assume they used an adequate amount of preservative.
The main reason bear spray hasn't caught on more than it has is that the reliability is not as good as a firearm nor is it as fast on the draw.

crimethink
29th August 2017, 12:42 PM
My bear spray is a S&W .44 Magnum. It sprays lead.

I had a large can of bear spray years ago and I had similar results when I tested it years after expiration. What usually goes wrong with spray products is partial solidification of the liquid resulting in clogging. Since pepper spray is an organic compound I assume they used an adequate amount of preservative.
The main reason bear spray hasn't caught on more than it has is that the reliability is not as good as a firearm nor is it as fast on the draw.

My preference is a rifle. Bear Spray has its place: when a firearm cannot be deployed, or by those who won't handle a firearm (stupid, but such is life).

osoab
29th August 2017, 05:23 PM
:D


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7JZzY3hawc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7JZzY3hawc

hoarder
29th August 2017, 08:35 PM
:D


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7JZzY3hawc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7JZzY3hawcNote to self:
If I ever make a youtube video of myself spraying bear spray, make sure I spray it downwind.

hoarder
29th August 2017, 08:37 PM
My preference is a rifle. Bear Spray has its place: when a firearm cannot be deployed, or by those who won't handle a firearm (stupid, but such is life).My preference would be a 50 caliber machine gun, but a 44 mag revolver is more along the lines of something I would be likely to be carrying in bear country unless it's elk season, in which case I would have my 3006.

hoarder
6th September 2017, 06:52 AM
Grizzly attack this weekend. Bear spray deployed.

http://missoulian.com/lifestyles/recreation/bear-spray-halts-grizzly-mauling-near-ennis/article_ccd2140f-4bb8-549f-bb69-7b2c21392e46.html

crimethink
6th September 2017, 11:54 AM
Grizzly attack this weekend. Bear spray deployed.

http://missoulian.com/lifestyles/recreation/bear-spray-halts-grizzly-mauling-near-ennis/article_ccd2140f-4bb8-549f-bb69-7b2c21392e46.html

His pistol was useless, too:

Sommer then grabbed his pistol and turned to confront the bear.

"It bit my thigh, ran his claws through my wrist and proceeded to attack my head," Sommer recalled Tuesday.

He still had his pistol in his hand and was going to shoot the bear in the neck when it swatted his arm down, Sommer said.

"Just like that it stopped. He stopped biting me, he got up and started to run away," said Sommer, who splits his time among Idaho, Missouri and Florida.

hoarder
6th September 2017, 12:33 PM
I imagine there are times when having a dog would help. You would be alerted a second or two earlier, giving you time to draw. But sometimes a dog will walk ahead and get into trouble with a predator and when chased, run home to daddy, bringing him to you.

Hitch
6th September 2017, 06:28 PM
Grizzly attack this weekend. Bear spray deployed.

http://missoulian.com/lifestyles/recreation/bear-spray-halts-grizzly-mauling-near-ennis/article_ccd2140f-4bb8-549f-bb69-7b2c21392e46.html

Thanks hoarder. From the article, the bear spray used by his buddy saved the guy's life. It initially slowed down the charge by the bear, then while he was getting mauled, his buddy used the spray and it chased the bear away before the bear could kill him.

It sounds like bear spray works and has it's uses, though I think a combo of spray and pistol would be ideal. That's what I intend to use, spray and a pistol as a backup when in bear country.

hoarder
6th September 2017, 06:59 PM
It's not uncommon for bears to maul and run, so it's uncertain that the mace did it. Sure didn't hurt.

Hitch
6th September 2017, 07:39 PM
It's not uncommon for bears to maul and run, so it's uncertain that the mace did it. Sure didn't hurt.

Roger that. Also, when the bear first charged, the spray didn't stop it, though slowed it down. Shows the adrenaline in a bear charge. I tend to think now this bear spray is more of a deterrent, not a life safety tool.

cheka.
6th September 2017, 09:53 PM
no bears for many of us - how effective is it on negroes?

Neuro
7th September 2017, 06:33 AM
no bears for many of us - how effective is it on negroes?

You should get out of liability if you glue a label over the bear spray can that says negrorepellant, and you claim you bought it in good faith. ;D

crimethink
7th September 2017, 10:31 AM
no bears for many of us - how effective is it on negroes?

Relatively docile Niggers? Probably works fine. Niggers on PCP? Useless.

hoarder
21st September 2017, 07:02 PM
To revive the subject of bears, we had an interesting incident about 60 miles from me. Fool animal lover tried to rescue injured big Black Bear.

http://missoulian.com/news/local/bear-in-back-of-pickup-supposedly-near-death-wasn-t/article_0aa66be3-6f6a-5613-9ad9-b4b16a8861cf.html

Tribal officer shot and killed it. The Feds don't seem to bother the Injun reservations, so lots of things there are handled sensibly. On the "rez", every gas station seems to sell guns and ammo.

Tumbleweed
21st September 2017, 11:32 PM
^ I wonder what they did with the bear. I had some hunters from Wisconsin bring me some brauts made out of bear meat and they were really good.